Recovery of phenotypically normal transgenic potato plants is facilitated by regenerating multiple lines from transformation events: field validation using a cry9Aa2 gene conferring insect resistance

A modified cry9Aa2 gene under the transcriptional control of the CaMV 35S promoter was transferred to four potato cultivars (‘Iwa’, ‘Karaka’, ‘Pacific’ and ‘Red Rascal’) using Agrobacterium-mediated gene transfer. Field plots were established for 170 independently regenerated transgenic lines derived from 113 transformation events. Phenotypic changes such as stunted plants, reduced vigour and/or leaf puckering, were observed in 29% of these lines. Foliage from the remaining 117 lines inhibited larval growth of potato tuber moth (Phthorimaea operculella Zeller) compared with non-transgenic controls. A high correlation was observed between greenhouse- and field-grown foliage for insect resistance using a detached leaf bioassay. Independently regenerated lines recovered from the same transformation event exhibited similar insect resistance. However, these lines derived from the same transformed cell differed markedly in phenotypic appearance and tuber yield. The first shoot regenerated from each transformation event was equivalent to the non-transgenic control for yield traits in only eight transformation events. A further 19 transformation events exhibited agronomic performance equivalent to the non-transgenic control when the second or subsequent regenerated shoots were evaluated. In clonal crops, multiple shoots from each transformation event should be independently assessed to ensure recovery of high-performing transgenic lines.